Select City
Search
user-profile
Airbnb or Paying Guest: A Profitable Comparison for Property Owners
Airbnb or Paying Guest: A Profitable Comparison for Property Owners
Confused between letting out your property as Airbnb or paying guest? Discover the pros, cons, costing factors, profitability, and legal considerations for both in India.

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. What is Airbnb?
  3. What is Paying Guest (PG)?
  4. Airbnb vs Paying Guest: Pros and Cons
  5. Costing and Profitability
  6. Key Considerations for Both Options
  7. Is Airbnb More Profitable than Renting?
  8. Conclusion
  9. Faq's

Introduction

When it comes to letting out a property, choosing between Airbnb and paying guest (PG) rentals can be challenging. While both options offer unique advantages, they cater to different audiences and serve distinct purposes. In this article, we'll break down the differences between Airbnb and PG, explore their profitability, discuss the costs involved, and review key legal considerations for letting out property in India.


Image Airbnb Vs. Pg (LinkedIn)

What is Airbnb?

Airbnb is a global platform that allows property owners to rent out their space, whether it's an entire home, a single room, or even unique stays like treehouses or yachts, to travelers on a short-term basis. It offers flexibility in terms of rental duration, pricing, and guest selection. The platform uses a dynamic pricing model, allowing hosts to adjust rates based on demand, season, and location. Airbnb is widely used in tourist-heavy areas, business hubs, and cities with events or festivals, making it a popular choice for both hosts and travelers.


Image Airbnb Home

What is Paying Guest (PG)?

Paying Guest (PG) accommodation is a long-term rental arrangement where tenants, often students or working professionals, rent a portion of a home while sharing common areas like kitchens and bathrooms with the landlord or other tenants. PG setups are typically furnished and may include additional amenities like meals, Wi-Fi, and laundry services. The rent is usually fixed monthly, offering property owners a steady, predictable income. PG accommodations are most common near universities, corporate hubs, or in residential neighborhoods with good connectivity and basic facilities.


Image Paying Guest (ZoloStays)

Airbnb vs Paying Guest: Pros and Cons

Factors Airbnb Paying Guest (PG)
Target Audience Short-term travelers, vacationers, or business travelers Students, working professionals, or long-term renters
Flexibility High flexibility to block dates, choose guests, and change rates Fixed monthly rental income with long-term tenants
Income Potential Higher profit margins due to dynamic pricing and demand spikes Steady but lower income with consistent monthly rentals
Management Effort Requires frequent cleaning, guest management, and online listings Minimal management, limited to periodic tenant supervision
Occupancy Risk Seasonal demand may lead to vacant periods Continuous occupancy, reducing risk of vacancies
Legal and Regulatory Requires adherence to short-term rental laws and local Airbnb regulations Comparatively simpler legal requirements but subject to tenancy laws

Costing and Profitability

  • Airbnb:

    • Revenue Potential: Higher revenue during peak seasons or events. For example, a property can earn ₹2,500-₹15,000 per night in cities like Mumbai or Goa.
    • Costs: Cleaning, maintenance, platform fees (usually 3%), and furnishing.
  • Paying Guest:

    • Revenue Potential: Average monthly rent ranges between ₹8,000-₹25,000 depending on location and amenities.
    • Costs: Basic furnishing and utility bills (if included in the rent).

Profitability: Airbnb can be more lucrative in high-demand tourist areas, but PGs offer stable and consistent income.

Key Considerations for Both Options

  • Location: Airbnb works well in tourist-heavy or business cities, while PG setups thrive near colleges or corporate hubs.
  • Time Commitment: Airbnb demands active management, whereas PGs require less involvement.
  • Market Demand: Study demand in your area before deciding.
  • Legal Compliance: Ensure you comply with laws for both options (discussed below).
  • Property Setup: Airbnb requires premium furnishings and décor, whereas PGs need basic amenities.

Is Airbnb More Profitable than Renting?

Airbnb can often be more profitable than traditional renting, including PG setups, depending on the location and demand. Here's why:

  • Higher Earnings Potential: 
    Airbnb allows dynamic pricing, meaning hosts can charge higher rates during peak seasons, festivals, or events. For example, a property in Mumbai or Goa might earn ₹3,000-₹5,000 per night, significantly more than the fixed monthly rent from a PG.

  • Flexibility:
    With Airbnb, property owners can rent their space only when it suits them, blocking dates for personal use. PG rentals, however, require long-term tenant commitments.

  • Guest Turnover:
    Airbnb hosts deal with short-term guests, which means frequent turnovers. This can lead to higher profits but also increased costs for cleaning, maintenance, and guest management. PG setups, on the other hand, involve less frequent tenant changes and lower associated costs.

  • Occupancy Risk:
    Airbnb income depends on occupancy rates, which can fluctuate due to seasonality or competition. PG rentals provide consistent monthly income, reducing financial risks.

Image Airbnb

Conclusion

Deciding between Airbnb and PG rentals depends on factors like location, effort, and income expectations. While Airbnb offers higher earnings in prime areas, PG rentals provide steady returns with less involvement. Evaluate your goals, market demand, and legal requirements to make an informed decision.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

explore further

NEED HELP?
Get in touch with Dwello consultant for free consultation
+91
Enquire Now
logo
A JM Financial Group Venture
HOW WE MAY HELP YOU?
(022) 6122 9411
hello@dwello.in
FOLLOW US
Registered & Corporate Office
JM Financial Products Limited. 7th Floor, Cnergy, Appasaheb Marathe Marg, Prabhadevi, Mumbai - 400025
CIN:
U74140MH1984PLC033397
RERA NUMBERS
maharera-icn
Maharashtra
A51900000277
karnatakarera-icn
Karnataka
PRM/KA/RERA/1251/309/AG/220521/002898
delhirera-icn
Delhi
DLRERA2022A0103
haryanarera-icn
Haryana
RC/HARERA/GGM/1932/1527/2022/300
What is Dwello?
Dwello is a new way to buy home. In a world where facts are chosen to suit interpretations, our algorithms offer accurate recommendations by sifting through vast knowledge banks comprising real time market data and historical decisions of many home buyers, curated by industry experts.
Dwello, for every home buyer, is a way to go from 'I feel' to 'I know', at no extra cost.
© 2023 JM Financial Products Limited. All Rights Reserved.